Image Source: AI Generated
I used to be uncomfortable with a world wired for instant gratification, validation, and the rush of something new. Then I realised I am not all that different. Sometimes I catch myself wondering: am I actually falling for this person, or is my nervous system reacting in ways that are supposed to feel like love? It is a little scary.
You keep wanting people who do not want you back because your nervous system has learned to read uncertainty as intensity, and intensity as love. Inconsistent attention works like a slot machine, projection turns a stranger into a character you wrote, and old family wounds make the chase feel like a chance to win. None of it is chemistry.
When I look back at my relationships, I cannot tell when real connection got blurred with everything else: attraction, anxiety, familiarity, the plain thrill of being wanted. So much can feel like love that it is hard to know what is real and what is my brain overcomplicating things. As a therapist, I see myself in clients all the time, asking the same messy questions and falling for the same patterns. It takes me back to every time I mistook chemistry for connection.
Are You Falling for the Person or the Performance?
As a hopeless romantic, I have play acted what I thought love should look like. I slipped into the role of the perfect girlfriend because the moment seemed to require it. I said "I miss you" and "I love this about you" because that is how relationships are supposed to sound, and not always because I meant it deeply.
The danger is that I did not fall for the person in front of me. I fell for their performance of love, and for my own. We crave connection so badly that we are willing to accept the illusion of it.
What Is the Difference Between Rejection and Indifference?
There is a difference between someone not choosing you and someone wanting nothing to do with you at all. Not being chosen still means you were considered, weighed, thought about, maybe even wanted, just not enough. Liking someone who feels nothing back is a different ache. There is no almost. No moment where you were in the running.
And yet we still do it. Sometimes I think it is because indifference does not argue with us the way rejection does. There is nothing to relive, no scene to replay, no "what if I had said this instead." Just silence, and silence is easy to fill with a story. So we fill it. We tell ourselves it is mysterious, or that they have not noticed yet, or that some people take longer to feel things. Anything other than the plain truth that they simply do not. We have written about why ambiguity in a relationship hurts more than a clear no, and this is that hurt at its most silent.
Are You Falling for Them, or for What They Give You?
At times I have been drawn to what someone lights up in me. The version of myself they bring out. They played the caregiver or the protector I needed at the time. They made me feel chosen in a way I had been craving.
The boy who brought out the child in me, at a time when I could not be one at home, became my definition of love. In reality all I felt was safe. All I needed was softness and a space to be myself. Growing up without many friends left an emptiness I was trying to fill, and he filled it. A romantic relationship met my need for someone who chose me every day. Someone who would not leave.
I was not falling for him. I fell for the need being met, and for the hope of the life I wanted.
Are You Seeing Them, or the Story You Wrote?
Our brains are suckers for a good story. Once they decide this could be love, they start collecting evidence to back it up. Selective attention does the rest. We ignore or justify everything that does not fit, because we are already invested in the version we built.
It gets worse for someone like me who grew up on Bollywood. When a person does something I have spent my whole life blushing over, or resembles my idea of romance in any way, I start cherry picking the good from the bad. This is projection: turning the other person into a screen for our own film. We do not see them as they are. We see who we want them to be, pieced together from our needs, our patterns, and the parts of us that still need healing.
Most of the time we are not falling for them. We are falling for the idea of them. When the real person shows up, messy and human and nothing like the role we cast them in, we are disappointed or confused.
If this person never changed, would I still want to be here?
That is the question I ask whenever I catch myself spiralling into the fantasy. It is a small reality check. A reminder to see the person in front of me and not the character my brain wrote.
Why Does Chaos Feel Like Connection?
Something I notice constantly in sessions: we are drawn to chaos. It comes down to how we were first introduced to closeness. If our earliest experiences were marked by unpredictable emotion and inconsistent love, our brains learn that instability and intimacy go together. As adults we are drawn to partners who run hot and cold, who are emotionally unavailable or otherwise unpredictable, and our nervous system mistakes that intensity for the familiar feeling of connection, even when it is stressful. If this sounds like your last three situationships, our piece on the signs of anxious attachment in Indian dating goes into the mechanism, and the attachment styles primer covers where it begins.
It took some work with a client (name withheld; shared with consent) to uncover how much her choice of men was tied to old wounds with her mother. She was, without quite knowing it, trying to prove her mother's constant criticism wrong by finding a man who made her feel good. If she could win over someone distant, out of reach, or even unkind, it felt like redemption. See, I am worthy after all.
The cost was that she kept gravitating toward men who could not give her the love and security she needed. The chase was about rewriting a painful story with a better ending. That made emotional sense, and it kept her stuck in a cycle of proving herself rather than being loved.
When you grow up with parents who made love feel like something to be earned, people who recreate that pattern feel familiar. Almost like home. Your brain whispers: this is my chance to finally win the love I did not get. That is not romance. It is an attempt to win, in the present, what you were not given in the past.
Our partners reflect the beliefs we hold about ourselves and have the power to reinforce them. That is why a client's self image, sense of worth and self esteem are the first things brought into awareness in therapy.
When these patterns start showing up as persistent low mood or heaviness rather than just relationship stress, working with a therapy for depression approach can help untangle the two.
I remember another client saying his girlfriend allowed him to be less angry with his parents for what they could not provide. He received from her the softness he had craved from them, and it let him be kinder to himself. Sometimes our partners are exactly what we wanted our parents to be. Sometimes we want them because they are the opposite of everything we resented.
Why Are We Addicted to Unpredictability?
Often what comes up in therapy is our addiction to not knowing. Like a casino machine, we do not win every time, and the not winning is what keeps us pulling the lever. When someone showers you with attention one day and goes silent the next, your brain becomes a gambler: maybe this time I will hit the jackpot. I will admit to checking my phone incessantly and refreshing my DMs. That one text feels like a sign of connection, and its unpredictability feels like intensity. It is just my nervous system chasing crumbs.
Part of this is enjoying the chase. Dopamine loves pursuit, so we confuse the thrill with love. Clients often treat an emotionally unavailable person as a rare collectible: hard to get, therefore worth having. The aloof, inconsistent, too busy person becomes a prize. It turns frightening when we start assuming they are better than us, and that this is why they do not want us.
That is not chemistry. That is scarcity running a small scam on your heart.
And here is the harder version. Sometimes clients go after people they know they cannot have. One client's dating history was a married man, a perpetually unavailable one, and someone three time zones away. Being with any of them let her avoid the actual vulnerability of a real, messy, everyday relationship. Her fear of loss and of relying on someone stayed safe, because intimacy never got real.
Are You Just Chasing the Opposite of Your Ex?
I keep falling for the classic opposite of my ex syndrome. Every time I see in someone a trait I wanted in my ex, or the reverse, a bulb lights up. The exact opposite of a toxic trait I hated looks like bliss, and I lose the ability to assess whether the person is right for me at all.
When we have been deprived of something for a long stretch, the simplest gesture can feel like intimacy. Relief is not the same as love. It is recency bias. My attraction is being set by my most recent wound.
What Does This Mean for How You Choose?
What I have arrived at, personally, is the uncomfortable realisation that I have gone after people who did not choose me fully because, deep down, I did not choose myself fully either. For a long time I believed that what I was asking for was too much, and the belief that I would eventually be left made me read every half compliment and delayed reply as gold.
That is not love. It is an old narrative reinforcing itself, keeping me in the same exhausting loop.
If that stuck feeling starts tipping into sadness, numbness, or hopelessness that doesn't lift, that's often a sign it's no longer just a relationship pattern - it's worth exploring with depression therapy in Mumbai.
Love, or what we mistake for it, is rarely about the person in front of us. It is about history, patterns, old wounds, and the stories our brains keep replaying. I am still figuring out what exactly I am drawn to: who they are, how they make me feel, or the potential I hope they will grow into. What I have learned is to slow down enough to notice the patterns I keep running, the stories I keep telling, and the roles I keep playing. If sorting chemistry from connection on paper would help, What Happens After Goodbye is the journaling tool we built for exactly that loop. And if the pattern is bigger than you can untangle alone, a therapist in Mumbai can help you see it from outside. I have not finished this work myself. I do not think anyone does.
What Else Do People Ask About Wanting People Who Don't Want Them?
Why do I like people who don't like me back?
Usually because uncertainty activates your nervous system, and that activation gets mislabelled as attraction. Intermittent attention is more habit forming than steady attention, so the person who is inconsistent feels more intense than the one who is reliably kind. Add projection, where you fill in the gaps with the person you want them to be, and the pull can feel like chemistry.
Is being attracted to unavailable people a sign of anxious attachment?
Often, though not always. Anxious attachment makes closeness feel necessary and perpetually at risk, which is exactly the state an unavailable partner keeps you in. Avoidant patterns can produce the same choices for a different reason: an unavailable person lets you avoid real intimacy while appearing to pursue it.
Why does a kind, available person feel boring?
Because your body has learned to read the absence of anxiety as the absence of feeling. When you are used to the spike and crash of an inconsistent partner, steadiness registers as flat. That is information about your nervous system, not a verdict on the person, and it usually shifts if you give steadiness longer than one meeting.
How do I stop wanting someone who doesn't want me?
Start by naming what the wanting is doing for you: proving worth, avoiding real intimacy, or replaying an old family script. Ask whether you would still want this person if nothing about them ever changed. Reduce the intermittent reward by stopping the checking. And if the pattern has survived several relationships and plenty of insight, it tends to shift in therapy rather than through willpower.
This piece is for understanding, not diagnosis. Client details are altered and shared with consent.
