5 CBT Tools Therapists Use to Quiet Your Inner Critic

5 CBT Tools Therapists Use to Quiet Your Inner Critic

"Inner critic is that voice which tells us how we are not good enough and that we are always lagging, unable to do things or maintain relationships."
 — Sonali Gupta, Psychologist

These words perfectly capture the nagging inner voice so many of us carry. It’s that persistent internal commentary of self-doubt, guilt, or harsh judgment. If you’ve ever heard a voice whisper, “You’re such a failure” after a mistake, or “You don’t deserve this” even when you succeed, you know the inner critic well. And trust me, you’re not alone.

Urban Indian women, especially, often grapple with an overactive inner critic. Blame it on the “good girl syndrome” – the pressure to be perfect, polite, and pleasing. Social conditioning teaches us to put others first and not rock the boat. As influencer Leeza Mangaldas confessed, trying to meet these expectations led to “an obsessive and quite destructive perfectionism as well as non-stop guilt” (Indian Express). These external messages often become internal mantras of shame. Psychologist Seema Hingorrany notes that women tend to “internalise all situations and start taking things personally; they cannot challenge their own negative thoughts” (Times of India).

Unchecked, this self-critical voice can chip away at our confidence and fuel anxiety, depression, and burnout (Talktoangel.com; PositivePsychology.com). The good news? You can declutter that inner critic and turn down its volume.

As a psychologist, I often help clients do exactly this. One of the most effective approaches is Cognitive-Behavioural Therapy (CBT) – a modality that helps us identify, challenge, and reframe unhelpful thoughts. Here are 5 CBT-based tools that therapists actually use in sessions to quiet the inner critic. Each one includes a real-life vignette and actionable advice.

 

Recognize and Name That Critical Voice

You can’t change what you don’t notice. Step one is to catch your inner critic in the act.

Try journaling your self-talk for a few days – jot down those sneaky thoughts like “I’m useless” or “I always mess up.” Once you spot the patterns, name that inner critic. It helps you separate it from your true self.

Priya, a client in her 30s, called her inner critic “Miss Not-Enough.” Now, when doubt creeps in, she says, “Oh, Miss Not-Enough is back,” and imagines setting her aside. That simple act gives her distance from the voice.

Why this works: Naming the critic creates psychological space. You realize the critic is a part of your mind – not the whole truth. This mindful detachment is key to disrupting automatic self-criticism.

 

Spot the Cognitive Distortions (aka Thought Traps)

The inner critic isn’t just mean – it’s often inaccurate. CBT calls these “cognitive distortions.”

Some common distortions:

  • All-or-Nothing Thinking: “If I’m not perfect, I’m a failure.”

  • Overgeneralization: “I made a mistake – I always mess things up.”

  • Personalization: “That friend is upset, so it must be something I did.”

Neha, a software engineer, was devastated after one critique during a code review. Her mind spiraled: “I’m not cut out for this job.” But when we broke it down, we identified three distortions: overgeneralization, catastrophizing, and personalization. Just seeing those thought patterns helped her take a step back.

Why this works: Naming distortions helps you realize your thoughts aren’t facts. It’s a powerful shift from “This is true” to “This is just one (biased) way of seeing it.”

 

Challenge the Thought Using a Thought Record

CBT therapists often use a “Thought Record” – a structured way to examine and reframe harsh thoughts.

Next time the critic strikes, ask:

What’s the thought?
What triggered it?
How do I feel?
What’s the evidence for and against it?
What’s a more balanced way of looking at this?

Sara, a media professional, felt sure she’d be fired for a typo in a client presentation. We worked through a Thought Record and realized: the client loved her ideas, her boss praised the deck, and the typo was minor. The more balanced thought? “It wasn’t perfect, but I did a great job overall.”

Why this works: A Thought Record helps you gather facts – not feelings – and reframe situations more realistically. Over time, it trains your brain to be fairer and less reactive.

 

Test the Thought with a Behavioral Experiment

Sometimes the best way to challenge the inner critic is to disobey it.

Example:

Inner critic: “You’ll embarrass yourself at that event.”
You: Attend the event for 30 minutes and chat with 2 people.

Anita, a young lawyer, believed she was “socially awkward” and would bomb at networking mixers. We created a mini experiment: go for 30 minutes and talk to just one new person. She ended up having three good conversations and even made a professional connection. Her critic? Proven wrong.

Why this works: Experiments gather real-life data. Even if things aren’t perfect, you often prove the critic’s worst-case scenario is exaggerated. With every action, you shrink the critic’s power.

 

Cultivate a Compassionate Inner Voice

You’re likely far kinder to your friends than to yourself. Let’s change that.

One powerful CBT question: “What would I say to a friend in this situation?”

Meera lost out on a promotion. Her critic went into overdrive: “You’re not leadership material.” But when I asked what she’d say to a friend in the same spot, Meera softened: “I’d remind her of her talents.” That became her new self-talk script.

Other ways to build your inner compassion:

Write a letter to yourself like you would to a close friend.
Keep a “positivity file” with praise, wins, and encouraging notes.
Practice saying kind things to yourself out loud.

Why this works: Research by Dr. Kristin Neff shows that self-compassion fuels motivation, not laziness. When we treat ourselves with care, we’re more resilient, not less.

 

 

A Gentle Reflection: Befriending Yourself

Decluttering your inner critic isn’t a one-time event – it’s a practice. But the tools are within reach.

You can:

Notice the voice

Label it

Challenge it

Experiment against it

And, most importantly, replace it with kindness.

It won’t happen overnight, but each time you pause and offer yourself understanding, you rewrite your inner narrative. In a world that pushes perfection, choosing compassion is radical. It's also healing.

You don’t have to be your harshest critic. You can be your strongest ally.

And you deserve that.

 

 

References (for the inquisitive minds):

Gupta, S. (2020). Anxiety: Overcome It and Live Without Fear. (Quotes on the “inner critic” and self-compassion)theblissfulstoryteller.comtheblissfulstoryteller.com.

Hingorrany, S. – Times of India Interview on women internalizing negativitytimesofindia.indiatimes.com.

Mangaldas, L. – Indian Express, Feb 2023, on “good girl syndrome” and perfectionism guiltindianexpress.com.

TalktoAngel Blog – Ways to Silence Your Inner Critic (recognizing and naming the inner critic)talktoangel.comtalktoangel.com and self-talk challengestalktoangel.com.

Hindustan Times – 8 Strategies to Silence Your Inner Critic (tips on awareness, evidence-testing)hindustantimes.com.

PositivePsychology.com – Living with the Inner Critic (CBT approach and thought records)positivepsychology.com and Dr. Kristin Neff’s self-compassion exercisepositivepsychology.com.

Anisha Kesarla (2025). The Illusion of Perfection: Overcoming Toxic Perfectionism – on embracing imperfectionthetalentedindian.com.

Back to blog